Watch Us In Your Living Room
Enjoy Very Local on the big screen.
Visit your favorite app store to download.

Polly’s Bywater Cafe on St. Claude is a Hidden Gem in Plain Sight

You can tell that the food here is made with care and love, and from that moment on you will have no other option than to return that devotion.

by Paula Echevarria
June 15, 2019

New Orleanians are not above foodie hype, but there’s something to be said about the underrated joints that we collectively, almost as if by an unspoken agreement, keep as hidden gems.

One of my favorite brunch spots in the city has hardly been written about or made its way into any top-10 listicle recognizing the usual suspects that herd locals and tourists alike come Sunday mornings. It’s an unassuming, neighborhood cafe in the
Bywater.

Polly’s Bywater Cafe is named after the owner’s rambunctious black and white boxer, whose colorful portraits will be the first thing that catches your eye when you walk into the diner. Tables are dressed with vinyl picnic tablecloths that alternate between the traditional shade of red, and aquamarine. Above the booth-lined wall, a collection of photographs by local artists provide small windows into New Orleans’ rich culture, ranging from portraits of musicians to the picturesque alleys of the French Quarter, to the familiar smiles of strangers.

It’s not packed busy, but it’s not empty, either. The one server on the floor greets me personally because he remembers that we’re namesakes. Paul is a darling white-haired man, with a tender shyness, that he only joyously breaks from when I ask if they have
Bloody Mary’s. “Oh, our Bloody’s are so delightful, you’re going to love them!”

The food takes a bit longer than usual to arrive, but you don’t mind it because this is the kind of place that makes you forget you own a smartphone. There’s nothing on the menu that would hint the food here is anything out of the ordinary, since it consists mostly of traditional breakfast and dinner staples.

But this misconception will leave you almost instantly the minute you put a bite of the comforting dishes in your mouth; you can tell that the food here is made with care and love, and from that moment on, you will have no other option than to return that
devotion.

Paul continues to weave himself in and out of our conversation, which has now shifted its focus to the warm fluffy biscuits that accompany the corned beef hash, or how the pan seared hogshead cheese on the Eggs Bywater — their take on Eggs Benedict –cuts the hollandaise sauce with the perfect mix of tangy and spicy. Pro tip: when ordering the Tumbled Home Fried, go all out and add your choice of meat and sauteed veggies, and don’t sleep on the specials board! It usually showcases the quiche-of-the-day, which I promise will become a hit on your Instagram feed.

Born in Madrid, raised in Miami, bred in New Orleans: Paula is a gregarious locavore always in search of a good cocktail and a great story. She won an Emmy for her kitchen production work while at NBCUniversal, and was nominated for a second one while working as the Associate Producer for PBS's Check, Please! South Florida with host, James Beard Award Winner, Chef Michelle Bernstein. While she worked as the Miami editor for national digital food and drink powerhouse, Tasting Table, she was chosen by Tom Colicchio as one of his secret diners for Bravo's Best New Restaurant. Food...

More Local Stories

Looking for a Dong Phuong king cake but can’t get to the East? Here’s a list of places that have them.

Live on the Westbank but still want to get a Dong Phuong king cake? No worries.

King cake flavored everything: is king cake flavor the new pumpkin spice?

Here’s a list of how your can get your King Cake fix if bread isn’t acceptable in your New Year’s diet.

Video: A Twisted Visit to The Pretzel Shop

The Pretzel Shop on Carson Street has been making pretzels by hand since 1927.

A guide to Christmas bar pop-ups in New Orleans

It wouldn’t be Christmas in New Orleans without a few magical cocktails and bar experiences to match! Here’s our guide to drinking your way into the holiday spirit this season.

A guide to Christmas bar pop-ups in New Orleans

It wouldn’t be Christmas in New Orleans without a few magical cocktails and bar experiences to match! Here’s our guide to drinking your way into the holiday spirit this season.

How King Cake Hub became the one-stop-shop for king cakes

Despite moving around the city and the death of one of its founders, the Hub continues being the only place you can get king cake from different bakeries under one roof.

20 Places to Enjoy a Safe and Very Merry Réveillon in 2021!

Obviously there’s some hesitancy by many to eat inside restaurants at the moment, so I did some research to find out which restaurants were available for take-out, outdoor seating or both! This way you can each this longtime tradition without putting yourself at more risk than you’re comfortable with. 

A big book of king cakes? Your guide is here.

Matt Haines’ 368-page book covers 75 bakeries and king cakes.

d’Livery brings local options to NOLA food delivery services

One local business owner set out to shake up the food delivery scene with a local option that better serves restaurants and drivers.

Top 5-04: Where to get some of the tastiest charcuterie boards in New Orleans

There are a lot of charcuterie options in town, so to make it easier we narrowed it down to the Top 5-04 charcuterie boards you should try!

Looking for a Dong Phuong king cake but can’t get to the East? Here’s a list of places that have them.

Live on the Westbank but still want to get a Dong Phuong king cake? No worries.

King cake flavored everything: is king cake flavor the new pumpkin spice?

Here’s a list of how your can get your King Cake fix if bread isn’t acceptable in your New Year’s diet.

Video: A Twisted Visit to The Pretzel Shop

The Pretzel Shop on Carson Street has been making pretzels by hand since 1927.

A guide to Christmas bar pop-ups in New Orleans

It wouldn’t be Christmas in New Orleans without a few magical cocktails and bar experiences to match! Here’s our guide to drinking your way into the holiday spirit this season.