Know Your NOLA: See Ya Later, Alligator? The Great American Alligator Museum ‘Opening Soon’ Is The Mystery Of The Lower Garden District

It’s “A 70-million-year-old tale waiting to be told,” according to the big bold letters on the glass of the Great American Alligator Museum. And it’s felt like it.

by Clint Durrett
July 15, 2018

It’s “A 70-million-year-old tale waiting to be told,” according to the big bold letters on the glass of the Great American Alligator Museum. And it’s felt like it.

The museum, located at 2051 Magazine Street, has sat essentially shuttered for years. The window displays change and all signs – from social media to physical ones – insist it is opening soon. However, the “Opening Soon” signs have been up for a while, crocodile.

https://www.facebook.com/alligatormuseum/photos/a.314941411981140.1073741828.314927458649202/1178594965615776/?type=3&theater

 

It’s a mystery worthy of an investi-gator.

(*ahem*)

Over the years, people in the Lower Garden District have all been keeping an eye on this reptilian repository. Many folks walk by it, wondering when “soon” will be “now.”

The museum is listed as “Permanently Closed” in the online search engine, Google. However, the museum’s operator and Facebook page boasts tantalizing, and curious, updates.

The Great American Alligator Museum (Listed on Google)
The Great American Alligator Museum is listed as permanently closed.

We tried reaching out to the museum. Voicemails left to the museum weren’t returned.

What is known from various published reports in New Orleans is that the museum was nearly ready to open in August 2005. Then, Hurricane Katrina hit. Since then, the struggle to open the museum is apparent.

Robert McDade, museum founder and propa-gator (*ahem*), launched an Indiegogo campaign in 2014. The goal was a lofty $450,000. A produced video was created for the campaign, which gives a glimpse of the inside decor and exhibits.

What McDade got was $590 total from 10 backers.

“Well folks, our campaign has come to a close and the results are a far cry from our goal. While this might make a normal person perceive the glass as half empty, fear not for we are an optimistic bunch,” McDade said at the close of the campaign.

Still to this day, people will walk up and attempt to open the door with a small sign, which says “Opening Soon.” Passersby will huddle by the windows, trying their best to get a peek in between the cracks of the window display.

The museum’s website hints at the spectacle within — a 50-million-year-old alligator fossil from Wyoming, a 10-million-year-old fossil from Florida among a nest of gator-related items.

People who have lived in the area for 20 years have noted that the museum’s opening seems more of a myth than anything else. However, some residents testify in the court of Facebook comments that they have been privileged with the opportunity of the magical tales of scales inside.

2051 Magazine St
Getting there
2051 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70130, USA

“I got halfway in the door once about 11 years ago,” Stoo Odom, a member of the Lower Garden District Facebook group, said. “ At the time, one of the owners was a woman I worked with at a bookstore in the ’90’s. She assured me it would be open soon… 11 years ago. I love alligators and would love to see it open.”

Molly McPherson said she went in one night during the “Art for Art’s Sake” stroll on Magazine Street almost eight years ago.

“It had all sorts of alligator memorabilia – salt & pepper shakers, alligator heads, a giant alligator in the middle of the room, etc.,” she said. “It was only open that evening at that point, as far as I could tell.”

Over time, though, optimism over the opening has faded. Residents lament over the closed doors of the museum with little hope to see them unlocked.

From “Don’t get your hopes up that it will open again” to “Hang in there!”, residents view it as a local mystery and legend.

The Great American Alligator Museum (Jan 17, 2017)
Don’t get excited. This is a photo from Jan. 2017. Le sigh.

Despite the cynicism from some residents of the Lower Garden District on the museum’s grand opening, McDade seems to have always been optimistic that eventually, things will be different.

“The museum project is still underway,” the museum’s website states. “One day it will open.”

We hope it’s not 70-million-years in the making.

 

Hi. I’m Clint. I’m the Local Market Manager for Very Local New Orleans. I’ve lived in New Orleans since 2001 and been living my best life in this rad place since that year. I have 10 years of broadcast journalism and digital media experience. Before Very Local New Orleans, I worked for WDSU-TV – producing, product developing, digital media managing– I’ve done it all. I’ve seen first-hand the trials we’ve suffered in this city and the celebrations we’ve enjoyed. I love New Orleans. It’s home. I’m going to work my hardest to bring you the content and experiences you care...

More Local Stories

Dream House Lounge is New Orleans’ first oxygen bar and wellness lounge

The downtown lounge is bringing soul to self-care.

Guide to the Barrel and Flow Pittsburgh Beer Festival

Barrel and Flow, the nation’s only beer festival in Pittsburgh to put people of color in the spotlight is back. August 13, 2022

Take a look inside the Duquesne Incline Museum

You can’t spell funicular without F-U-N. Grab two quarters – tours are just 50 cents – and step into the year 1877’s finest in transportation technology.

Reading along the River: A guide to New Orleans independent bookstores

These 12 indie bookstores can help you find your next read and connect you to the greater New Orleans community.

Eat Play Stay: Natchitoches

In this episode of Eat Play Stay, explore Natchitoches, Louisiana, the oldest settlement in the Louisiana Purchase territory.

Not Your Average Cup of Joe: Unique Coffee Houses in Orlando

Here are three unique coffee shops where the cup of joe isn’t the only thing that’ll get you moving.

Top 407: the best breakfast sandwiches in Orlando

Here is a list of locally-owned spots to get your breakfast sandwich fix.

My Amazing Cheap Date: Orlando Festivals & Stand-Up Comedy

On this episode of “My Amazing Cheap Date” two couples explore bliss on a bun and get their game on. – for $50 or less.

What’s on the Menu: Pretty Plates

This episode of What’s on the Menu Baltimore is all about digging into the aesthetics of a perfectly plated dish and exploring the power of a beautifully designed restaurant.

Eat Play Stay: Lexington, SC

Fill your glass at a local winery, bite down on a gourmet biscuit, and cuddle up in a carriage house. Find this and more things to do in Lexington, S.C. on this episode of “Eat Play Stay Greenville.”

dream house new orleans

Dream House Lounge is New Orleans’ first oxygen bar and wellness lounge

The downtown lounge is bringing soul to self-care.

Take a look inside the Duquesne Incline Museum

You can’t spell funicular without F-U-N. Grab two quarters – tours are just 50 cents – and step into the year 1877’s finest in transportation technology.

independent bookstores

Reading along the River: A guide to New Orleans independent bookstores

These 12 indie bookstores can help you find your next read and connect you to the greater New Orleans community.

glamping new orleans

Here’s where to go glamping in New Orleans

These trips are less than a day away from New Orleans.